How to Terminate or Fire a Remote Employee in India

Letting go of an employee can be a sensitive process, but with the right approach, it can be handled efficiently even for remote workers in India. By understanding the legalities involved, you can avoid potential complications and ensure a smooth transition for both parties.

Disclaimer: The information contained in this blog is for general informational purposes only and should not be construed as legal advice. Employment termination in India is a complex legal matter, and the specific requirements and procedures will vary depending on the circumstances of each case.

In addition to the law, wrongful termination can lead to discussions on online communities hampering the image of the company, as you can see in this subreddit forum, which has been widely discussed and upvoted.

View the Post

To ensure the termination is smooth and free of legal hassles, it is important to understand the local laws and acceptable practices. This guide will walk you through the key steps to legally terminate remote employees in India, keeping you on the right side of federal, state, and company policies.

Legal Framework in India

The Legal Framework in India is slightly complicated compared to many countries. This complexity stems from the interplay of both federal and state laws. Let's understand the key legal players involved in employee termination:

Image Credit

• Concurrent Jurisdiction: Unlike some countries, labor and employment regulations in India are concurrent subjects, meaning both the federal government and individual states have the authority to enact laws. This creates a layered legal landscape that employers must navigate.
• Federal Statutes: Two primary federal statutes govern employee termination:some text
  • Industrial Employment (Standing Orders) Act (IESA), 1946: This act establishes procedures for disciplinary action and termination for establishments with more than 100 employees.
  • Industrial Disputes Act (IDA), 1947: This act focuses on retrenchment (termination due to redundancy or closure) and outlines specific requirements for providing notice and compensation.
• State-Specific Legislation: Adding another layer of complexity, individual states have their own Shops and Establishments Acts which may also contain provisions related to employee termination, particularly for smaller establishments. These state-specific acts can vary significantly, so employers must be aware of the relevant regulations in the state where the remote employee is located.

Example:

The Karnataka Shops and Establishments Act, 1961: This act requires one month's notice for termination for employees who have completed more than six months of service.

The Kerala Shops and Establishments Act, 1964: This act mandates 30 days' notice for termination after six months of service.

In the next section, we'll discuss the types of termination in India, ensuring compliance with all applicable laws.

Types of Termination

It's important to understand the various reasons an employment relationship might end. These reasons can be broadly categorized as either voluntary or involuntary termination.

• Voluntary Termination: In this scenario, the employee chooses to leave the company due to personal or professional reasons. A formal resignation letter is typically required, with a standard notice period of 30 days. This can go up to 90 days based on the contract.
• Involuntary Termination: This category encompasses situations where the employer initiates the termination of the employee's contract. Here are some of the common types of involuntary termination:some text
  • Layoffs and Downsizing: When a company needs to reduce its workforce due to economic reasons, restructuring, or mergers, layoffs or downsizing may occur.
  • Dismissal for Misconduct: If an employee engages in serious misconduct or persistently underperforms, they may be subject to dismissal after a proper disciplinary inquiry with notice, charges, and an opportunity to respond.
  • Illegal Dismissals: Indian law prohibits discrimination-based termination based on factors like caste, gender, or race. Additionally, protections are in place for employees on maternity leave or whistleblowers who report wrongdoing.
  • Termination for Convenience: This type of termination occurs based on a predefined clause within the employment contract. The contract will typically outline a standard notice period that the employer must provide in these situations.

Understanding the type of termination will be crucial when determining the applicable notice period and severance pay requirements, which we'll explore in the next section.

Notice Requirements and Severance Pay

Following a discussion on the various reasons for employee termination in India, let's delve into the crucial aspects of notice periods and severance pay. These requirements are essential for ensuring a compliant and fair termination process.

• Notice or Payment in Lieu: Indian law generally mandates that employers provide a notice period or pay in lieu of notice when terminating an employee's contract. This requirement exists to provide the employee with time to find new employment and ensure a smooth transition. However, there are exceptions to this requirement. In cases of proven employee misconduct, such as theft or insubordination, the employer may not be obligated to provide notice or severance pay.
• Severance Pay for "Workmen": The federal Industrial Disputes Act (IDA) mandates the payment of retrenchment compensation to certain categories of employees. These employees are typically referred to as "workmen" and generally include blue-collar workers and those employed in factories, mines, or plantations. The retrenchment compensation is calculated as 15 days of average pay for every completed year of service, providing some financial security for the terminated employee.
• Severance Pay for "Non-Workmen": For employees who fall outside the definition of "workmen," such as managerial or senior-level staff, severance pay is typically determined by the terms of their employment contract. In these cases, there's no federally mandated severance package. However, a well-drafted employment contract will often outline severance pay provisions that are negotiated between the employer and the employee.

Understanding notice period and severance pay requirements is essential for employers in India to ensure compliance with labor laws and fair treatment of terminated employees. 

In the next section, we'll discuss the challenges companies encounter during the termination process in India, along with the solutions.

Terminating Remote Employees in India: Challenges & Solutions

When terminating a remote employee in India, additional considerations arise beyond the standard notice and severance pay requirements. 

Let’s understand this with an example specific to India to see the challenges that come forth and the solutions to resolve them.

Example: Firing a Remote Employee - Challenges and Solutions

Akash, a software developer based in Bangalore, India, works remotely for a US-based tech company. Due to consistently missed deadlines and unresponsive communication, the company decides to terminate Akash's employment.

Challenges

• Legal Compliance: Indian labor laws require a specific termination process, including potential notice periods and severance pay. Understanding these legalities is crucial to avoid legal disputes.
• Communication Gap: Delivering bad news remotely can be impersonal and lead to misunderstandings. Akash might feel blindsided or lack clarity on the reasons for termination.
• Data Security: Since Akash worked remotely, ensuring secure retrieval of company data and access to internal systems is important.

Solution

• Consult HR and Legal: Collaborate with HR and legal professionals experienced in Indian employment law. They can guide on proper termination procedures, and potential severance packages, and ensure compliance.
• Schedule a Video Call: Schedule a video call with Akash to deliver the news personally. This allows for clearer communication and opportunity for questions.
• Prepare Documentation: Prepare a clear termination letter outlining the reasons and effective date. Include details on final pay, benefits continuation (if applicable), and data return procedures.
• Data Return Protocol: Have a pre-established process for retrieving company equipment and ensuring secure deletion of company data from Akash's devices.
• Positive Outcome: The company can ensure a respectful and legal termination process for Akash by following these steps. Akash will receive clear communication and necessary documentation. This minimizes the risk of confusion or legal issues.

By following these steps and prioritizing clear communication, proper record-keeping, and state-specific legal compliance, employers can navigate the termination process for remote employees in India with greater confidence. 

In the next section, we'll provide some best practices to ensure a smooth and respectful termination experience for both the employer and the employee.

Termination Procedure in India

Termination is painful for both the employee and the employer. Every step of termination must be done by the book and respecting the prevalent culture in India. This is expected from the employer. Here are the steps expected of you during the process of termination.

1. Review Internal Policies and Contracts 

Before initiating any formal proceedings, it's crucial to consult your company's Human Resources (HR) policies and the employee's employment agreement. These documents will outline any specific protocols or procedures that must be followed during the termination process. 

2. Formal Notice of Termination

Once you've reviewed the relevant policies and agreements, a formal notice of termination needs to be served to the employee. The format and content of this notice will depend on whether the termination is based on statutory requirements (such as retrenchment under the IDA) or contractual terms. It's important to ensure the notice adheres to all legal and contractual obligations.

3. Gratuity Payment

Eligibility: Employees who have completed at least five years of continuous service are entitled to gratuity upon termination, except in cases of serious misconduct.

Calculation: Gratuity is calculated at 15 days' wages for each completed year of service. Wages include basic salary, dearness allowance, and any other cash component paid regularly.

Payment: The employer must pay the calculated gratuity amount within 30 days of the employee's last working day.

Important Points Regarding Gratuity:

• The Payment of Gratuity Act, of 1972, governs gratuity payment in India.
• The act applies to establishments employing ten or more people.
• The act specifies the maximum gratuity amount that can be paid (currently Rs. 20 lakh).
• There might be variations in eligibility or calculation methods depending on specific company policies or collective bargaining agreements.

4. Full and Final Settlement (FFS)

Full and Final Settlement (FFS) refers to the process of clearing all outstanding dues owed to an employee upon termination of their employment in India. This ensures the employee receives all their rightful compensation and relieves the employer of any future claims. Here's a breakdown of the key components of a Full and Final Settlement in India:

Components of Full and Final Settlement:

• Outstanding Salary: This includes any unpaid salary for the period worked up to the last working day.
• Unused Leave Encashment: If the employee has any unused leaves like earned leave, sick leave, or special casual leave (depending on company policy or state laws), the employer might offer to compensate for these in cash. The encashment amount is typically calculated based on the employee's last drawn salary.
• Reimbursements: If the employee has incurred any legitimate business expenses that haven't been reimbursed yet (e.g., travel expenses, and phone bills), these should be included in the FFS.
• Statutory Dues: The employer is responsible for depositing the employee's and employer's contributions to various social security schemes like:
• Provident Fund (PF): Employee Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952
• Employees' State Insurance (ESI): Employees' State Insurance Act, 1948 (applicable for certain industries and wage thresholds)
• Professional Tax (PT): Varies by state
• Gratuity (if applicable): As explained earlier, gratuity is payable to employees who meet the eligibility criteria (minimum 5 years of service, no serious misconduct).

Settlement Process and Timeline

• The employer usually prepares a Full and Final Settlement statement outlining the breakdown of all components mentioned above.
• Once both parties agree, the employee typically signs a document acknowledging receipt of the full and final settlement amount.
• Ideally, the FFS should be completed and paid out along with the employee's last drawn salary.

Importance of a Clear FFS

• A clear and well-documented Full and Final Settlement protects both the employer and the employee.
• It minimizes the risk of future disputes regarding unpaid dues.
• It helps maintain a positive separation experience for the employee.

5. Relieving Documentation

When an employee's contract is terminated in India, the employer has a responsibility to provide them with specific documents to finalize the separation process. 

These documents serve as official records of employment and aid the employee in their future job search. Here's a breakdown of the key relieving documents typically issued:

• Termination Letter

This formal letter officially informs the employee about the termination of their employment. It should clearly state the effective date of termination (usually the last working day).

The letter should also mention the reason for termination. However, confidentiality needs to be maintained regarding any sensitive details, especially in cases of misconduct.

• Relieving Letter

A relieving letter is a document issued by the employer stating that the employee has been relieved from their duties and has no outstanding dues with the company.

It typically includes details like the employee's name, designation, date of joining, and date of relieving.

This document is crucial for the employee as it serves as proof of their previous employment and their good standing with the company.

• Experience Certificate

An experience certificate verifies the employee's work experience with the company. It usually includes details like the employee's name, designation, employment period, and the nature of their job responsibilities.

In some cases, the certificate might also mention the employee's performance during their tenure. However, employers should avoid including negative remarks unless necessary.

6. Employer of Record (EOR) and Termination in India

Terminating an employee in India can be complex and time-consuming, especially for international companies unfamiliar with the legalities.

Here's where an  Employer of Record (EOR) can be a lifesaver:

• EOR Handles Termination Process: If you hire employees in India through an EOR, they take the responsibility of managing the entire termination process in accordance with Indian labor laws.
• Notice Period and Settlement: The EOR will handle communicating the notice period, and calculating the final settlement amount including salary, leave encashment, and statutory dues like gratuity.
• Documentation: The EOR will issue all necessary termination documents like the termination letter, relieving letter, experience certificate, and full and final settlement statement.
• Statutory Payments: The EOR ensures all statutory payments reach the employee, minimizing any delays or non-compliance issues.

Benefits of Using an EOR

• Reduced Risk: The EOR shoulders the legal responsibility for following termination procedures correctly, minimizing the risk of disputes or penalties for your company.
• Time Efficiency: The EOR handles the administrative tasks, freeing up your team's time to focus on core business activities.
• Expertise: EORs have the knowledge and experience to navigate the complexities of Indian labor laws and ensure a smooth termination process.

Get in touch today with Wisemonk experts to learn more about our EOR services and how they can simplify your employee management in India, including terminations. We can help you navigate the legalities and ensure a smooth separation experience for both you and your employee.

7. Exit Interview (Optional but Recommended)

While not mandatory, conducting an exit interview can be a valuable tool. This conversation allows you to gather feedback from the departing employee on their experience at your company. Additionally, an exit interview provides an opportunity to ensure a smooth handover of ongoing projects or responsibilities and maintain a professional parting.

Following a clear and well-defined termination process is essential for employers in India. By adhering to these steps, you can ensure compliance with legal requirements, minimize the risk of disputes, and maintain a professional relationship with the departing employee. 

In the next section, we'll explore the grounds for termination in detail.

Grounds for Termination

Having established a structured termination process, let's see the specific grounds for employee termination that are considered lawful in India. Understanding these justifications will help employers make informed decisions when considering employee termination.

• Common Reasons for Termination: Several actions or behaviors by an employee can constitute valid grounds for termination in India. These commonly include:some text
  • Insubordination: Refusal to follow lawful instructions or directives from superiors.
  • Fraud: Deception or dishonesty that is material to the employment relationship.
  • Habitual Negligence: A consistent pattern of carelessness or failure to perform duties to a satisfactory standard.
  • Disorderly Behavior: Conduct that disrupts the workplace or creates a hostile work environment.

NOTE: Indian Law offers specific protections for certain categories of employees, including pregnant women. The Maternity Benefit Act of 2017 outlines clear restrictions on terminating the employment of pregnant women or those on maternity leave. Employers must be mindful of these legal safeguards to avoid potential legal repercussions. 

Important: Legal Principles the Supreme Court of India Uses to Determine Wrongful Termination Cases

The Supreme Court of India applies several key legal principles to determine wrongful termination cases. These principles are outlined below:

• Reinstatement Not Automatic: Reinstatement is not an automatic remedy for wrongful termination. Courts can award compensation instead based on the facts and circumstances of the case.
• Jurisdiction: The appropriate jurisdiction for availing remedies against wrongful termination depends on the nature of the relief claimed and the right sought to be enforced. Civil courts have jurisdiction if the dispute is not an industrial dispute or does not relate to the enforcement of rights under industrial laws.
• Mitigation of Damages: Courts apply the principle of mitigation of damages from the Indian Contract Act, Section 73. This means that the quantum of damages awarded must be reasonable in the context of the employment agreement, and the employee's efforts to mitigate their losses are considered.
• Industrial Law and Specific Performance: For workers, industrial law empowers industrial tribunals to award reinstatement and compensation. However, reinstatement is not granted as a matter of rule and is subject to relevant facts and circumstances.
• Reasonable Opportunity to Defend: The dismissal of a servant by a statutory authority or body is invalid if it does not comply with the provisions of the statute or scheme regulating the exercise of their power. The employee must be given a reasonable opportunity to defend themselves against the proposed action.
• Compensation and Restitution: If the employer is found liable for wrongful dismissal, the court can direct the employer to compensate the employee and restore their service. The employer can also be penalized.
• Specific Grounds for Termination: Termination for any reason other than disciplinary action is treated as retrenchment, which requires a written notice period and compensation. For misconduct, an inquiry must be conducted following the principle of natural justice.

These principles guide the Supreme Court of India in determining the appropriate remedies for wrongful termination cases, ensuring that the rights of both employees and employers are protected.

In the next section, we'll discuss the significance of compliance in the termination process for employers in India.

Importance of Compliance

We've established a framework for navigating employee termination in India, but why is strict adherence to legal procedures and established grounds for dismissal so crucial? Here's a closer look at the importance of compliance:

• Mitigating Risk: Employee termination, even when handled with the best intentions, can lead to disputes. A compliant termination process minimizes the likelihood of costly lawsuits, government penalties, and reputational damage that can arise from wrongful termination claims.
• Protecting Your Company: Beyond legal considerations, a compliant termination process protects your company's reputation. Following a well-defined and compliant process demonstrates your commitment to fair treatment of employees, even during a separation.
• Promoting Transparency and Trust: When termination is handled openly, transparently, and following the law, it fosters trust and understanding among remaining employees. They see a fair and consistent approach being followed, which can alleviate anxieties and maintain a positive work environment.

In conclusion, a compliant termination process goes beyond legal requirements. It safeguards your company financially and protects its reputation. It also fosters trust with employees and ensures fairness for everyone involved.

In the next section, we will discuss the legalities that you may get involved in, in case of wrongful termination.

Employee Protections and Court Jurisdiction

While employers have legal obligations during termination, Indian law also offers protections for employees. Understanding these rights and the potential avenues for dispute resolution is crucial for employers to navigate the termination process effectively.

• Right to Challenge Termination: Employees in India have the legal right to challenge a termination they believe is wrong or unfair. This means they can file a complaint against the employer for violating their legal rights during the termination process.
• Dispute Resolution Channels: If a dispute arises, several channels exist for employees to seek redressal. These can include:some text
  • Jurisdictional Conciliation Officers: These officers attempt to mediate a settlement between the employer and employee.
  • Industrial Tribunals: Established in specific industries, tribunals adjudicate disputes related to termination and other employment matters.
  • Labor Courts: These courts handle a broader range of labor disputes, including wrongful termination claims.
• Documentation is Key: Strong documentation is key for both employers and employees during termination in India. Keep records of performance issues, communication, and termination notices. This protects your position in disputes and emphasizes clear communication, minimizing legal risks.

Given the potential legal complexities and the importance of employee rights, employers need to prioritize best practices throughout the termination process. 

In the next section, we'll summarize the key recommendations to ensure a smooth termination experience for both employers and employees in India. 

Final Recommendations and Best Practices

Navigating employee termination in India, particularly for remote employees, can involve complexities beyond the legal framework. By following these best practices, employers can ensure a smooth, compliant, and respectful experience for all parties involved:

• Prioritize Documentation: Maintain a comprehensive record of all relevant documents throughout the employment relationship. This includes performance reviews, disciplinary warnings, communication records, and termination notices. Thorough documentation will be your strongest defense in case of any disputes.
• Develop Clear HR Policies: Having a well-defined company policy outlining termination procedures is essential. This policy should be communicated clearly to all employees, including remote workers. A transparent policy ensures everyone understands the process and their rights and obligations.
• Consider Separation Agreements: In some cases, utilizing separation agreements can be beneficial. These agreements outline the terms of the termination, including severance packages and non-disparagement clauses. While not mandatory, they can help ensure a clean break and minimize the risk of future legal challenges, allowing both parties to move forward on good terms.

Terminating a remote employee in India requires following legal guidelines and best practices. This includes understanding notice periods, severance pay, clear communication, and proper documentation. By following a well-structured process, you can ensure a fair and compliant termination, minimizing risks and maintaining a positive work environment.

How can WiseMonk Help?

WiseMonk can simplify the process of terminating a remote employee in India in several ways:

• Compliance Expertise: They can help ensure you adhere to the complexities of Indian labor laws and regulations specific to remote work. This includes navigating federal and state requirements, understanding notice periods, and severance pay obligations, and ensuring compliance with employee protections.
• Contracts & Documentation: WiseMonk can assist with maintaining proper contracts and documentation throughout the employment relationship. This includes records of contracts, performance reviews, communication related to disciplinary actions, and termination notices. Having a clear paper trail is crucial for minimizing risks in case of disputes.
• Indian Expert Guidance: Their team of specialists can provide guidance on best practices for remote employee termination in India. This includes clear communication strategies, adhering to a well-defined termination process, and potentially utilizing separation agreements to ensure a smooth parting.
• Reduced Administrative Burden: WiseMonk can handle the administrative tasks associated with termination, such as calculating severance pay and managing payroll deductions. This frees up your time and resources to focus on core business operations.

Considering the complexities involved, navigating employee termination in India can be a challenge. Contact WiseMonk's team today to discuss your specific situation and explore how their expertise can ensure a compliant and efficient termination process.

Bibliography

• Indian Constitution (1949) - https://legislative.gov.in/constitution-of-india/
• The Industrial Employment (Standing Orders) Act, 1946 (Act No. 20 of 1946) - https://clc.gov.in/clc/acts-rules/industrial-employment-standing-orders-act-1946
• The Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (Act No. 14 of 1947) - https://labour.gov.in/sites/default/files/THE-INDUSTRIAL-DISPUTES-ACT-1947.pdf

• Ministry of Labour and Employment, Government of India: https://labour.gov.in/
• International Labour Organization (ILO) - India: https://normlex.ilo.org/dyn/normlex/en/f?p=1000:11110:0::NO:11110:P11110_COUNTRY_ID:102691
• https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=4617803e-887b-465a-9556-247efacf834e
• https://main.sci.gov.in/jonew/judis/6616.pdf
• https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2017/19634/19634_2017_40_23_32009_Judgement_10-Dec-2021.pdf
• https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/how-to/what-to-do-in-case-of-wrongful-termination-of-employment/articleshow/86983537.cms